close this window
Anti-Smoking Ads Can Be Counterproductive
Fear is effective. So is disgust. But combining them is too much — at least when it comes to public service announcements aimed at getting people to stop smoking.
In a new study to be published in an upcoming issue of the journal Health Communication, University of Missouri researchers examined the effect of a variety of anti-tobacco ads. Using electrodes placed on viewers’ facial muscles, they measured their physiological response to a series of 30-second spots.
Some of the ads focused on fear, noting that smoking has been strongly linked to lung cancer and heart diseases. Others featured unpleasant graphic imagery such as blood and bodily organs. A third category featured both a fear message and repugnant imagery.
The researchers found that both the fear-based and disgust-heavy ads increased viewers’ attention and memory. However, ads combining the two factors decreased attention and memory.
“When fear and disgust are combined in a single television ad, the ad might become too noxious for the viewer,” said lead author Glenn Leshner, co-director of the Psychological Research on Information and Media Effects Lab at the Missouri School of Journalism. He and co-author Paul Bolls said they hope this insight will help in designing more effective anti-smoking messages.
“We noticed several ads in our collection of anti-tobacco public service announcements that contained very disturbing images, such as cholesterol being squeezed from a human artery, a diseased lung or a cancer-riddled tongue,” Leshner said. “Presumably, these messages are designed to scare people so that they don’t smoke. It appears this strategy may backfire.”
word on the street
more in this section
Bitter About Your Life? Blame Facebook
Miller-McCune’s Top Stories of 2011
Pop Charts Still Dominated by Men
Two Russian Films Give Differing Views of Motherland
Securing Nebulous Privacy Rights in the Cloud
Searing Look at Rio’s Homicidal Police
PBS to Show ‘Where Soldiers Come From’
Civil Rights Groups’ Surprising Net-Neutrality Bedfellows
Call Us Names (Or At Least, Give Us Some …)
Culturomics 2.0 Aims to Predict Future Events
also by this author
Tom JacobsStaff writer Tom Jacobs is a veteran journalist with more than 20 years experience at daily newspapers. He has served as a staff writer for The Lo...
The Perceived Delicacy of the Female ConductorNew research finds listeners judge symphonic music differently when they’re told the conductor is a woman.
Pressure to Conform Can Inspire CreativityNew research suggests less-creative people do more innovative thinking when they are told individualism is the norm, and instructed to conform.
Children’s Books Increasingly Ignore Natural WorldA survey of award-winning children’s picture books from 1938 to 2008 suggests our increasing estrangement from the natural environment.
Women Eye Dance Moves to Find Thrill SeekersHow to spot thrill-seeking men on the dance floor, “sweet” personalities in public, and bidding fever on eBay.
Morning People May Be More Creative in the AfternoonNew research finds problems that require a flash of illumination to solve are best approached during the time of day when you’re not at your peak.
Receive 1 year (6 issues) of our print magazine for just $14.95. Miller-McCune features polished, in-depth reports on research and solutions across the policy spectrum — from health care, education and energy to international affairs, poverty and the global economy. It's a must read for well-informed and solutions-driven individuals.
follow us on:
join our newsletter:
from the source
The wage gap between the sexes in America has been closing much faster than anyone realized, but that’s tempered by learning it’s been much wider than measurements had shown.
An effort to identify five performing orcas as slaves failed in part, argues one scholar, because there’s no legal precedent establishing them as persons.
Transportation used to be one of the few guaranteed areas of agreement when ideology trumped pragmatism in D.C. But that’s no longer the case.
A lot of people say they watch the Super Bowl mostly for the ads. But it turns out a good game surrounding those ads makes them seem better.
After decades of obstacles hindering the voting process, new laws will allow overseas and military voters to submit their votes in time for the 2012 election.
