Thursday, September 9, 2010   |  Return To Homepage

more in this section

also by this author

Tom Jacobs

Tom Jacobs is a veteran journalist with more than 20 years experience at daily newspapers. He has served as a staff writer for The Los Angeles Dai...

The Scientist and the Journalist Can Be Friends

Nancy Baron’s new book is an excellent guide for academic researchers on how to effectively communicate with the press, public and policymakers.

An Emotional Timeline of Sept. 11, 2001

German researchers, analyzing the content of text messages sent on 9/11/01, report that while sadness and anxiety levels remained stable through the day, anger steadily increased.

Volunteer Work Prolongs Lives of Frail Elderly

New research finds that among the elderly, functional limitations are associated with an increased risk of dying — but only for those who don’t do volunteer work.

Public Defenders as Effective as Private Attorneys

New research suggests that, in terms of influencing key judicial decisions, public defenders are as effective as their private counterparts.

The Magnetic Appeal of a Meaningful Life

A sense one’s life has meaning increases one’s allure in social situations, according to new research.

How Polling Places Can Affect Your Vote

Researchers argue the physical location of the polls not only affects how many people vote; it may also influence last-minute decisions regarding which box to mark or lever to pull.

For Some, Anger Inspires Creativity

Want to get those creative juices flowing? Try having someone scowl at you.

Married Couples Don’t Grow More Alike Over Time

New research finds scant evidence for the notion that, in terms of personality, couples grow more similar to one another over time.

Forgiveness, Resentment and Blood Sugar?

New research links diabetic symptoms with a reduced likelihood of forgiving others.

What We Miss When We Obsess Over Obesity

Social epidemiologist Paula Lantz reveals what actually leads to premature deaths among Americans. Obesity? No. Poverty? Yes.

Receive 1 year (6 issues) of our print magazine for just $24.95. Miller-McCune features polished, in-depth reports on research and solutions across the policy spectrum — from health care, education and energy to international affairs, poverty and the global economy. It's a must read for well-informed and solutions-driven individuals.

close this window


We encourage you to share any articles or material you find on Miller-McCune.com with friends and colleagues. Please fill in the fields below with the name and e-mail address. Then fill in the same information for you. Miller-McCune will not keep any information about you or your friend, and the e-mail your friends receive will appear to have come from your e-mail address. The asterisk (*) denotes a required field.


From:





To:







Findings

February 18, 2009

Carbon Capture the Economical Approach to Climate Change?

 


| PRINT | E-MAIL

In spite of the scientific consensus regarding climate change, much of the mainstream media continues to regard the issue as a matter of debate. But while columnists such as George Will use outdated or erroneous statistics to foster doubt, more serious thinkers are considering the pros and cons of various methods for reducing the concentration of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere.

In a newly published paper, Roger Pielke Jr. of the University of Colorado’s Center for Science and Technology Policy Research asserts that “air capture” – that is, direct removal of carbon dioxide from the air – deserves far more serious consideration than it has received to date. According to his calculations, extracting carbon dioxide from the atmosphere and sequestering it underground is potentially more economical than other proposed methods of dealing with the problem.

In the journal Environmental Science and Policy, Pielke writes that “the costs over the 21st century of deploying air capture to fully stabilize greenhouse gas emissions are comparable to, and under some assumptions more favorable than, the costs of stabilization presented by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change.” He argues that “more attention should be paid to research, development and deployment” of this technology.

Scientists have proposed a variety of methods for extracting and capturing carbon dioxide from the air, including a prototype developed by Columbia University. The gas would then be sequestered, possibly by the use of “peridotite carbonation, a natural geologic process involving rock that reacts with carbon dioxide,” Pielke writes.

In 2007, carbon dioxide was measured in the atmosphere at a concentration of 380 parts per million – a huge increase from several hundred years ago, when the concentration was approximately 280 parts per million. Climate scientists assume the concentration will continue to rise in the coming years, but hope to stabilize it at 450 parts per million by the year 2040.

The cost of capturing and sequestering enough carbon dioxide to reach that level has been estimated at anywhere from $100 to $500 per ton. Even using the $500 per ton figure, air capture over the course of the 21st century would cost “about the same” as the emissions-stabilization efforts proposed by the IPCC. At $100 per ton, the cost would be “much less” than other proposed remedies, Pielke notes.

Focusing in on one specific component of the problem, Pielke writes that all automobile emissions of carbon dioxide in the U.S. could be offset through air capture at a cost of $48 billion (at $100/ton) to $240 billion (at $500/ton). That would require a relatively small increase in gasoline taxes, to a maximum of $1.60 per gallon. American drivers could capture their carbon dioxide emissions and “still have among the lowest gasoline prices in the world,” he writes.

Pielke concludes that these surprising and encouraging results suggest “at a minimum, that air capture should receive the same detailed analysis as other approaches to mitigation.”

Share and Enjoy:
  • Add to favorites
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Slashdot
  • Fark
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Mixx
  • Google Bookmarks
  • LinkedIn
  • Technorati
  • Live
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • MySpace
  • NewsVine
  • Twitter
 

word on the street

Post your comment here

Leave a Reply

follow us on:

join our newsletter:


from the source

Gas Mileage Labels Get Sophisticated

The federal government has unveiled updated designs for those informational stickers on new cars. The hope is to nudge buyers into choosing more fuel-efficient models.

California Rejects Ban on Plastic Bags

Lawmakers struck down a bill that would have made California the first state in the union to ban plastic shopping bags.

Do School Lunches Plump Up Poor Kids?

A program to ensure all American children get at least one good meal a day may lie behind their expanding waistlines. Oddly, a breakfast program does not.

Liberals Gone Wild

A short digression on the meaning of a word that apparently has no generally agreed-upon political definition.

The Balance of Evil-Doing: Kiri’s Impacts

Having completed his 5,000-mile voyage, Kristian Beadle weighs his trip’s carbon use and examines whether the benefits balance the costs.